Recently, on a board I frequent, a heated debate is going on regarding the topic “public schools vs. private schools.”  It seems to be a powder keg issue.  One poster (who doesn’t have any children, by the way) states that she believes that children can thrive in any educational environment, as long as they have been instilled with a love of learning.  The parents amongst us simply roll our eyes and ignore her.   Schools do matter, and non-parents just don’t get it.

But it got me thinking: are public schools automatically worse than private?  I can only speak for Japan (and to a certain extent, NZ in the 70s-80s as I was educated there in the public school system, which was excellent in those days).  I’ve been on both ends of the spectrum as a mother.  As a child Sonbeam attended a 10k a year private school, where he and I both had a hard time because he had trouble getting to grips with English, the student body was made up of spoilt expat kids, and the teachers – who moved on every couple of years – were only in Japan for the high salaries, and obviously didn’t care about their students.   Neither of us regret it though, because he made very valuable contacts there that he maintains to this day. 

Later on he attended an inner-city public school that was ranked as one of the worst in Hyogo Prefecture, where he absolutely thrived, and received an amount of pastoral care that astonished me.  The overworked, underpaid Japanese teachers there routinely went above and beyond the call of duty for their young charges, some of whom had very difficult home lives.  I credit those teachers with instilling in him a love of learning that continues to this day. 

So, which is better?  I really can’t say, but I do wish to challenge the notion that private education automatically equals better education.  That’s not always the case, after all.


4 comments on “Edumacation

  1. Jeni says:

    I agree with you, Miko. Ahmee is getting an excellent public education now but she did also get an excellent private school education in Singapore. Having skilled and caring teachers is what makes the most difference with a private or public school.

  2. Petra says:

    From the teachers I know in the US I know for a fact that only true dedication keeps them in the public system – and true dedication makes for a good teacher, doesn’t it?

  3. Miko says:

    Yes, indeed the dedication and skill of the teachers makes all the difference, but there’s only so far it can go, especially in Japan where class sizes are large (as many as 40 pupils), and the beleagured teachers have to deal with clueless administrators and ridiculous government policies that change every other year.

    As you know, in my experience teaching cram school to both private and public school students, I’ve noticed a *huge* gap in terms of ability and motivation. If I ever have grandkids here I’m going to insist that they go to a private school. Just to be on the safe side.

  4. Karen says:

    As you all pointed out, though, there are some public schools that are excellent. That’s one of the reasons we moved to this town 32 years ago. The schools were very highly ranked in the state.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s